While MMA is the ultimate clash of styles, fierce stylistic rivalries exist amongst more specialized combat styles. In the striking domain, one of the fiercest such rivalries is between Muay Thai and Dutch kickboxing.
The two styles have dominated the standup fighting world outside boxing for decades. But what are they exactly? Muay Thai is a combat sport coming out of Thailand. At the same time, Dutch kickboxing is a specific fighting and training method in western kickboxing. Still, it became so successful that it became known as a distinct style.
Typically, these style vs. style comparisons is purely theoretical. But, in this case, Muay Thai and Dutch kickboxing have long clashed and influenced each other in the real world. Let’s see how they stack up against each other and then look at some legendary battles that shaped and defined this rivalry.
Dutch kickboxing is an approach to kickboxing that was developed in the Netherlands and became so stereotypical that it’s considered a style of its own. Dutch kickboxing was heavily influenced by Kyokushin karate, Japanese kickboxing, and Muay Thai.
But the strongest influence was and remains Kyokushin, which gave the aggression and fast pace to Dutch kickboxers.
The Dutch kickboxing style features high volume attacks, predominantly punches, often finishing the combinations with hard low kicks. Dutch fighters fight at a high pace and always try to maintain forward momentum and aggressive striking.
The history of kickboxing in the Netherlands began in the 1970s when Dutch karatekas traveled to Japan and learned Kyokushin karate and Japanese kickboxing, which they later started to teach in their homeland. In time, the style developed into its own thing.
While Muay Thai also impacted its development, the core remains western-style boxing combinations with karate aggression and vicious kicks.
The result of the development of kickboxing in Holland was more than impressive. During the golden age of kickboxing in the 1990s and 2000s, 15 of the 19 World Grand Prix kickboxing world champions were Dutch.
The national sport of Thailand, Muay Thai, is a brutal striking sport characterized by punches, kicks, elbows, knees, and extensive clinching techniques.
Discover The Little Known Secrets For Unlocking Devastating KO Power!
The sport has developed over centuries and can be traced back at least to the 13th century. Like many other martial arts, it was born on the battlefield, but unlike most, it has not lost much of its edge and effectiveness.
The introduction of western boxing changed the ancient martial art in Thailand at the beginning of the 20th century. Implementing the boxing ring, timed rounds, and boxing gloves (which replaced wrapping the hands with ropes) made the sport essentially what we know today.
Aside from the techniques and rules, a big difference between Muay Thai and other modern combat sports is the rich traditions Muay Thai is steeped in.
Every fight begins with a ritual dance called a Wai Kru. Fighters wear ceremonial elements on their heads and arms, and traditional Sarama music accompanies the fight at all times.
The global success and fame of Muay Thai came in the 1990s and 2000s when it clashed with the world of kickboxing. Many foreigners traveled to Thailand to fight at the stadiums, and Thai fighters started fighting at the World Grand Prix, which hugely popularized the Thai style among the western world. Then the rise of MMA saw Muay Thai implemented as the main striking style of choice of many MMA fighters.
Dutch Kickboxing vs. Muay Thai Key Differences
Muay Thai fights are usually fought in 5 rounds of 3 minutes each in a square boxing ring. Fights are scored as a whole, and each next round holds more significance than the previous one.
Strikes are allowed with every part of the limbs. Clinching is very important and allowed, as are trips, dumps, and throws (although not every kind of throw).
Dutch kickboxing is not a separate sport but a style within kickboxing, so we will cover the rules of K-1 style kickboxing used in all the major organizations in the world and the Netherlands. Punches and kicks are allowed, while elbows are not.
Knees can also be used, but not extensively in the clinch like in Muay Thai. Clinches are very limited, to the point where in some organizations, they are immediately broken apart by the ref. Fights are scored round by round, like in boxing.
Dutch kickboxers use punching techniques very similar to boxing, with the addition of the backfist and superman punch. High volume, heavy punching is synonymous with this kickboxing style. Dutch fighters also have a specific way of kicking, especially the low kick.
It’s a Kyokushin-style full-force kick coming across the thigh and landing with the shin. Obviously, some fighters use various kicks, but the most common way is this. Another staple of this style is the step-in knee and the jumping knee developed to land knees without the need for clinching.
Muay Thai fighters do not rely on punches that much, and most are thrown as single strikes without that much commitment. However, they can use elbows, which are the preferred weapon up close and in the clinch and one of the defining strikes in Muay Thai. Knees are also very popular and used in many different ways and purposes across all ranges.
Teeps are well utilized, but roundhouse kicks are what earn the most of the fearsome reputation of Thai fighters. The Thai way of kicking may not be the fastest or most precise, but it sure is the most powerful.
Another difference is how Dutch stylists and Thais block kicks. Thai fighters prefer to check all kicks except high kicks with their legs. Dutch kickboxers employ a double arm cross block that leaves the defender in a position to deliver a powerful counter punch.
From the first moment you watch Muay Thai and kickboxing matches, you will see a stark contrast in pace. The K-1 kickboxing rules were created to guarantee entertaining and fast-paced fights. The Dutch kickboxers are masters at this game and push the pace from the first bell. Aggression and high volume are always desired and employed.
Thai fighters fight in a completely different way. The first round is always reserved for feeling things out between competitors and the crowd (bets are usually placed during the first round). The pace gradually builds as the fight progresses, with the last two rounds being the culmination of the fight.
Fighters mostly rely on powerful single strikes and well-timed counters. Of course, fighters like Saenchai and Samart Payakaroon break out of this model entirely. Still, the majority of the fights play out as described. On the flip side, modern top fighters like Rodtang fight much more like a Dutch stylist than a Thai.
The Dutch and Thai training methods are also quite different. Reflective of their fighting style, Dutch kickboxers train at a high pace. They have used the give and take partner drills so extensively that they have generally become known as “Dutch kickboxing drills.”
This is a training method in which both trainees use their gloves like pads and hold them for their partner to drill combos. The moment the sequence is finished, the other person repeats the combo. This way, there is no need for a trainer to hold pads, and everyone gets to work all the time.
Thai fighters mainly train on pads with an emphasis on power. The coach holds Thai-style pads (covering the forearm) and body shields. Trainers often wear shin guards and throw strikes to keep the fighter guessing. Each training session also includes clinch training.
Sparring etiquette also differs significantly. The Dutch have become famous for their hard sparring, almost resembling a fight. Nak Muay spar very lightly most of the time because they fight often.
They even have a word for the concept of relaxed sparring-Sabai. Both methods have benefits and drawbacks, but we will not dwell on them here.
Dutch Kickboxing vs. Muay Thai For Self Defense
This will be a hard line to draw. Muay Thai should have the edge based on the extended arsenal of weapons at its disposal. Clinch skills are also invaluable in these situations. But in reality, the way Dutch kickboxers fight might be better suited for real life.
There is no time to gauge the opponent, and take your time. A hard, fast, and aggressive approach is probably the best for self-defense, and this is precisely the method of Dutch kickboxing.
Both styles are excellent for MMA. The use of knees, elbows, and clinching is a perfect lend in the cage, and Muay Thai has been the top choice for striking art for most MMA fighters for quite some time.
However, Dutch kickboxing is also very good as a base. Where traditional Muay Thai is very lacking in punching offense and defense, as well as footwork patterns and movement, kickboxers have a serious edge. Of course, both styles need some work to work in the cage.
The upright rear foot-heavy posture in Muay Thai makes it an easy target for wrestlers. And the complete lack of grappling in kickboxing means the kickboxer will have more skills to learn in the transition into MMA.
There is no need for me to answer the question, as the answer has been tested repeatedly in both avenues. The rivalry began in 1982 when 4 Dutch fighters traveled to Thailand, and all four lost.
With these lessons learned and game plans adjusted, kickboxers like the legendary Ramon Deckers and Rob Kaman started beating Thais.
Deckers became a Lumpinee stadium champion and a Thai celebrity, influencing the sport with his vicious punching combinations and proving some of the limitations of the traditional Thai style.
Then, a decade later, Buakaw exploded onto the scene and stormed the K-1 World Grand Prix, beating Dutch legends like Albert Kraus and Andy Sour in kickboxing rules.
The style battle continues today in arenas like One FC and Glory Kickboxing. New generations of Muay Thai fighters and Dutch kickboxers continue to battle for the supremacy of their style and fighting philosophy. A prime example of a more modern classic is the five fights between Marat Grigorian and Sitichai.
Both styles have a lot to offer, and it boils down, just like always, to personal preference. This preference may very well be determined by the accessibility of gyms in the region. Some countries have a well-developed Muay Thai scene, others a better kickboxing one. Both have amateur ranks and serious possibilities for professional development at a world-class level.
Choose the one closest to your heart or closer to your home. If you have only one option, grab it without hesitation.